Harmonized Standards and Common Specifications: Articles 8 and 9 of the Tıbbi Cihaz Yönetmeliği, Presumption of Conformity and ÜTS

SUMMARY
Harmonized standards are European standards whose reference numbers have been published in the Official Journal of the European Union, under Article 8 of the Tıbbi Cihaz Yönetmeliği (Medical Device Regulation). Devices that conform to these standards are presumed to conform to the requirements covered by the standard.
Common specifications are in Article 9: where there is no standard, where it is insufficient, or in the case of public health concerns, the requirements published by the Commission apply. In this post we give the two Articles, the definitions and the ÜTS side as verbatim quotations.
For the ÜTS document and product registration of your device: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Contents
1. Two Definitions
Article 3 of the Regulation:
“(ııı) Harmonized standard: a European standard adopted at the request of the Commission for the application of harmonized European Union legislation,”
“(öö) Common specifications: a set of technical and/or clinical requirements, other than a standard, that provides a means of complying with the legal obligations applicable to a device, process or system,”
2. Art. 8(1): Presumption of Conformity
“ARTICLE 8 - (1) Devices that are in conformity with the relevant harmonized standards, or the relevant parts of those standards, the references of which have been published in the Official Journal of the European Union, shall be presumed to be in conformity with the requirements of this Regulation covered by those standards or parts thereof.”
Condition: the reference number of the standard has been published in the Official Journal of the European Union.
Scope: the presumption arises for the requirements covered by the standard or the relevant part of it.
Conformity with the relevant parts of the standard also counts.
The continuation of the same paragraph applies the presumption to system and process requirements as well:
“The first subparagraph shall also apply to system or process requirements to be fulfilled in accordance with this Regulation by economic operators or sponsors, including those relating to quality management systems, risk management, post-market surveillance systems, clinical investigations, clinical evaluation or post-market clinical follow-up (PMCF). References in this Regulation to harmonized standards shall be understood as meaning standards the references of which have been published in the Official Journal of the European Union.”
For post-market surveillance, see our posts on post-market surveillance and PSUR; for clinical evaluation, our post on clinical evaluation and PMCF.
3. Art. 8(2): European Pharmacopoeia Monographs
“(2) References in this Regulation to harmonized standards shall be understood to include also the monographs of the European Pharmacopoeia, provided that their references have been published in the Official Journal of the European Union, in particular monographs on surgical sutures and monographs on the interaction between a medicinal product and the materials used in devices containing such medicinal products.”
4. Art. 9(1)-(2): When Common Specifications Apply
“ARTICLE 9 - (1) Without prejudice to point (b) of the third paragraph of Article 1 and the fifth paragraph of this Article, the thirteenth and fourteenth paragraphs of provisional Article 1 and the fifth paragraph of Article 17, and the deadlines stated in those provisions, where there are no harmonized standards or where the relevant harmonized standards are insufficient, or where there is a need to address public health concerns, the common specifications published by the Commission apply with regard to the general safety and performance requirements set out in Annex I, the technical documentation set out in Annexes II and III, the clinical evaluation and post-market clinical follow-up set out in Annex XIV, or the requirements on clinical investigation set out in Annex XV.”
“(2) Devices that are in conformity with the common specifications referred to in the first paragraph shall be presumed to be in conformity with the requirements of this Regulation covered by those common specifications or the relevant parts of them.”
Cases: there is no harmonized standard, the standard is insufficient, or there is a public health concern (9(1)).
Fields: Annex I, Annexes II and III, Annex XIV, Annex XV (9(1)).
For a conforming device, conformity with the covered requirements is presumed (9(2)).
5. Art. 9(3): Justification of an Equivalent Solution
“(3) Manufacturers shall comply with the common specifications referred to in the first paragraph unless they can duly justify that they have adopted solutions ensuring a level of safety and performance that is at least equivalent to them.”
The manufacturer complies with the common specification. If it duly justifies that it has adopted a solution ensuring at least an equivalent level of safety and performance, it may adopt a different solution.
6. Art. 9(4)-(6): Annex XVI Products and Cumulative Compliance
“(4) Manufacturers of the products listed in Annex XVI shall comply with the relevant common specifications for those products, notwithstanding the third paragraph.”
“(5) The common specifications for each group of products listed in Annex XVI shall address, at least, the application of risk management as set out in Annex I for the group of products in question and, where necessary, the clinical evaluation regarding safety.”
“(6) Where a device has both a medical and a non-medical intended purpose, those devices shall cumulatively fulfil the requirements applicable to devices with a medical intended purpose and those applicable to devices without a medical intended purpose.”
The fourth paragraph says “notwithstanding the third paragraph”: the route of justifying an equivalent solution is not written for Annex XVI products. Point (b) of the third paragraph of Article 1 also states that the Regulation will apply to Annex XVI products from the date of application of the common specifications adopted under Article 9. For the Annex XVI product groups, see our post on Annex XVI products without a medical purpose.
7. Technical Documentation and Place in the Declaration
Under Section 4 of Annex II, demonstrating conformity includes the following:
“(c) the harmonized standards, common specifications or other solutions applied; and”
One of the items of information to be included in the EU declaration of conformity under Annex IV:
“7. References to any common specifications used and in relation to which conformity is declared,”
Under Annex VII, the notified body also takes these into account:
“Onaylanmış kuruluş, imalatçı uygun olduğunu iddia etmese dahi, ilgili olduğu hallerde, mevcut ortak spesifikasyonları, kılavuz ve iyi uygulama dokümanlarını ve uyumlaştırılmış standartları dikkate alır.”
For the other contents of the declaration, see our post on EU declaration of conformity and CE marking; for the reference to applied standards in the SSCP, see our post on SSCP.
8. The ÜTS Side: Declaration Template and Symbols
The MDR declaration of conformity template in Annex 7 of the TCKKD-KLVZ-03 guide contains the following line:
“Ürünün uygun olduğu diğer AB Mevzuatı / Ortak Spesifikasyonlar / Uyumlaştırılmış Standartlar” (Other EU Legislation / Common Specifications / Harmonized Standards to which the product conforms)
“Sections beginning with (*) are mandatory.”
This line is not marked with (*) in the template. For the symbols in the instructions for use, Article 17 of the guide:
“Kullanılan her sembol veya tanımlama rengi, uyumlaştırılmış standartlara ya da ortak spesifikasyonlara uygun olur. Uyumlaştırılmış standartların veya ortak spesifikasyonların bulunmadığı alanlarda, bu semboller ve renkler, cihazla birlikte temin edilen dokümantasyonda açıklanır.”
For the document upload steps, see our post on ÜTS document registration.
9. Frequently Asked Questions
Does complying with a harmonized standard mean conformity with all requirements?
No. Under the first paragraph of Article 8, the presumption arises for the requirements covered by the standards or the parts of them.
Is it required that the reference of the standard has been published?
Under Article 8, the presumption arises for standards whose reference numbers have been published in the Official Journal of the European Union. References to standards in the Regulation are understood in the same way.
When do common specifications apply?
Under the first paragraph of Article 9, when there is no harmonized standard, when the relevant standard is insufficient, or when there is a need to address public health concerns.
Can a solution different from the common specification be applied?
Under the third paragraph of Article 9, yes, if the manufacturer duly justifies a solution ensuring at least an equivalent level of safety and performance. Under the fourth paragraph, manufacturers of Annex XVI products comply with the common specifications notwithstanding the third paragraph.
Which requirements apply to a device with both a medical and a non-medical purpose?
Under the sixth paragraph of Article 9, the two groups of requirements are met cumulatively.
For the ÜTS document and product registration of your device: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Sources



