Defective Medical Device: Consumer Rights Under Law No. 6502, Joint Liability of Importer and Producer, and ÜTS Return Notification

SUMMARY
A defective medical device is subject to the defective goods provisions of the Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 when sold to a consumer. The Law defines the defect, gives the consumer four optional rights, and holds the seller, producer and importer jointly liable for repair and replacement requests.
In this article we give, with verbatim quotations (unofficial translation), Articles 3, 8, 10, 11, 12 and 56 of the Law, the relevant provisions of the Warranty Certificate Regulation, and the ÜTS notification made when a device sold to a consumer is returned. The article is a compilation of legislation; it does not replace legal advice in a specific dispute.
For your ÜTS registration and individual notification procedures: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Contents
1. Whom the Law Protects: Definitions of Consumer, Seller and Importer
2. What Is Defective Goods: Law Article 8
3. For the First Six Months the Burden of Proof Is on the Seller: Article 10
4. The Consumer's Four Optional Rights: Article 11
5. Joint Liability of the Producer and Importer
6. The Thirty Working Day Rule
7. Limitation Period: Two Years, at Least One Year for Second-Hand
8. Health Products Requiring a Warranty Certificate
9. The ÜTS Equivalent of a Returned Device
10. Defect and Serious Adverse Event Reporting Are Separate Obligations
11. Frequently Asked Questions
1. Whom the Law Protects: Definitions of Consumer, Seller and Importer
Law No. 6502 covers every kind of consumer transaction. The definitions in Article 3 of the Law (unofficial translation):
“k) Consumer: A natural or legal person acting for non-commercial or non-professional purposes,”
“i) Seller: A natural or legal person, including public legal entities, who offers goods to the consumer for commercial or professional purposes, or who acts in the name or on behalf of the one who offers goods,”
“e) Importer: A natural or legal person, including public legal entities, who places goods or services, or the raw materials or intermediate goods of such goods, on the market by sale, lease, financial leasing or a similar method, by importing them for commercial or professional purposes,”
These provisions are for sales to consumers. The warranty certificate for devices sold to healthcare service providers is regulated separately in the Regulation on Medical Device Sales, Advertising and Promotion; for this, see our article on medical device warranty certificate and technical service.
2. What Is Defective Goods: Law Article 8
“ARTICLE 8- (1) Defective goods are goods that, at the time of delivery to the consumer, are in breach of contract because they do not conform to the sample or model agreed by the parties or do not have the characteristics they objectively should have.”
“(2) Goods are also considered defective if they lack one or more of the characteristics stated on their packaging, label, in their introduction and instructions for use, on the internet portal, or in advertisements and announcements; if they are contrary to the quality declared by the seller or determined in their technical regulation; or if they contain material, legal or economic deficiencies that do not meet the intended use of equivalent goods or that reduce or eliminate the benefits the consumer reasonably expects.”
The second paragraph lists the label, the instructions for use, the internet portal and advertising. A device that does not have the characteristics stated in these places is defective. Installation is also covered:
“(3) Failure to deliver the goods subject to the contract within the period agreed in the contract, or failure to install them properly where installation is carried out by the seller or under the seller's responsibility, is considered non-conforming performance. Where installation is intended to be carried out by the consumer, if installation is faulty due to an error or deficiency in the installation instructions, non-conforming performance occurs.”
For how the label and instructions for use are checked in the ÜTS record, see our page on ÜTS product image and label rules.
3. For the First Six Months the Burden of Proof Is on the Seller: Article 10
“ARTICLE 10- (1) Defects that appear within six months from the delivery date are presumed to have existed on the delivery date. In this case the burden of proving that the goods are not defective rests with the seller. This presumption does not apply if it is incompatible with the nature of the goods or the defect.”
If the consumer knows of the defect at the time of the contract, there is no non-conformity:
“(2) Where the consumer was aware of the defect on the date the contract was concluded, or could be expected to be aware of it, there is no non-conformity. The consumer's optional rights against defects other than these are reserved.”
A label is mandatory for defective goods offered for sale. The same paragraph states that a product not in conformity with its technical regulation cannot be placed on the market in any way:
“(3) A label containing explanatory information on the defect of the goods, which the consumer can easily read, shall be placed by the producer, importer or seller on the defective goods to be offered for sale or on their packaging. It is mandatory that this label be given to the consumer or that the explanatory information on the defect be clearly shown on the invoice, receipt or sales document given to the consumer. Products not in conformity with their technical regulation cannot be placed on the market in any way.”
4. The Consumer's Four Optional Rights: Article 11
“ARTICLE 11- (1) If the goods are found to be defective, the consumer may;”
“a) Withdraw from the contract by declaring that they are ready to return the goods,”
“b) Keep the goods and request a reduction of the sale price in proportion to the defect,”
“c) Request free repair of the goods, with all costs borne by the seller, provided that it does not require excessive expense,”
“ç) If possible, request replacement of the goods with a non-defective equivalent,”
“exercise one of the optional rights. The seller is obliged to fulfil the request preferred by the consumer.”
The choice is the consumer's. If repair or replacement would cause disproportionate difficulty for the seller, the consumer uses one of the other two rights:
“(3) If free repair or replacement of the goods with a non-defective equivalent would involve disproportionate difficulties for the seller, the consumer may exercise one of the rights of withdrawing from the contract or reducing the price in proportion to the defect.”
Refund and costs:
“(5) Where the consumer chooses the right to withdraw from the contract or to a price reduction in proportion to the defect, the entire price paid or the amount of the price reduction is refunded to the consumer immediately.”
“(6) All costs arising from the exercise of the optional rights are borne by the party fulfilling the right chosen by the consumer. Together with one of these optional rights, the consumer may also claim compensation under the provisions of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 dated 11/1/2011.”
5. Joint Liability of the Producer and Importer
The repair and replacement rights are not only against the seller. Article 11, second paragraph:
“(2) The rights of free repair or replacement of the goods with a non-defective equivalent may also be exercised against the producer or importer. The seller, producer and importer are jointly liable for fulfilling the rights in this paragraph. The producer or importer is not held liable if it proves that the defect arose after the goods were placed on the market by itself.”
Joint liability is for the repair and replacement rights. Withdrawal from the contract and price reduction are not listed in this paragraph. For the importer's obligations under the medical device legislation, see our article on importer and distributor obligations.
6. The Thirty Working Day Rule
“(4) Where one of the rights of free repair or replacement of the goods with a non-defective equivalent is chosen, it is mandatory that this request be fulfilled within a maximum of thirty working days, or sixty working days for residential and holiday properties, from the date it is directed to the seller, producer or importer. However, for goods in the list annexed to the regulation issued under Article 58 of this Law, the consumer's request for free repair is fulfilled within the maximum repair period set out in the regulation. Otherwise the consumer is free to exercise the other optional rights.”
The thirty working days is for repair and replacement requests. For goods in the list annexed to the After-Sales Services Regulation, repair is subject to the maximum repair period in that regulation. The Warranty Certificate Regulation defines a working day as follows:
“d) (Amended: OG-5/11/2020-31295)(1) Working day: Working days other than national, official and religious holidays and New Year's Day, 1 May, 15 July and Sundays,”
7. Limitation Period: Two Years, at Least One Year for Second-Hand
“ARTICLE 12- (1) Unless a longer period is specified in laws or in the contract between the parties, liability for defective goods is subject to a limitation period of two years from the date of delivery of the goods to the consumer, even if the defect appears later.”
“(2) Subject to the third paragraph of Article 10 of this Law, the seller's liability for defective goods in second-hand sales cannot be less than one year, or three years for residential or holiday properties.”
“(3) The limitation provisions do not apply if the defect is concealed by gross negligence or fraud.”
8. Health Products Requiring a Warranty Certificate
Article 56 of the Law imposes the warranty certificate obligation on producers and importers:
“ARTICLE 56- (1) Producers and importers are obliged to issue a warranty certificate, the content of which is determined by regulation, for goods produced or imported for consumers. The responsibility of completing this certificate and giving it to the consumer rests with the seller.”
“(2) The warranty period is a minimum of two years, starting from the delivery date of the goods.”
The Warranty Certificate Regulation covers only the goods in its annexed list. The following items appear in the "HEALTH PRODUCTS" section of the list with a 2-year warranty period:
1.1 Personal-use devices: blood pressure monitors, blood value measuring devices, hearing aids, speech devices, thermometers, massage tools and devices
1.2 Mother and child products: electronic breast pumps, bottle warmers, bottle sterilizers, baby food preparation sets, child car seats, high chairs, baby carriages and strollers, baby monitoring cameras and parent monitors
1.3 Devices for the disabled: wheelchairs, battery-powered vehicles for the disabled, book readers for the visually impaired
An invoice does not replace a warranty certificate, and the time spent in repair is added to the warranty period:
“(3) Invoices issued for the goods sold do not replace the warranty certificate.”
“(3) In the event of a breakdown of the goods, the time spent in repair is added to the warranty period.”
In cases of repeated breakdown during the warranty period, exceeding the maximum repair period, or the impossibility of repair, Article 9 of the regulation applies:
“In these cases, the consumer may request from the seller a refund of the price of the goods, a price reduction in proportion to the defect or, if possible, replacement of the goods with a non-defective equivalent. The seller cannot refuse the consumer's request. If this request is not fulfilled, the seller, producer and importer are jointly liable.”
These rights do not apply to a breakdown caused by use contrary to the instructions for use:
“(1) The provisions of Articles 8 and 9 do not apply to breakdowns resulting from the consumer's use of the goods contrary to the matters set out in the introduction and instructions for use.”
9. The ÜTS Equivalent of a Returned Device
Individually tracked devices sold directly to citizens by a sales center are notified in ÜTS with a "Notification of Delivery to Consumer". Individual Movement Notifications Guidance, Article 14:
“Article 14- (1) A "Notification of Delivery to Consumer" is made for medical devices sold directly to citizens by the sales center.”
“(6) If the Notification of Delivery to Consumer was made incorrectly, it is cancelled with a "Cancellation Notification of Delivery to Consumer".”
“(7) When a medical device sold directly to a citizen by the sales center with a Notification of Delivery to Consumer is to be returned, a "Notification of Return Received from Consumer" is made for the number of products to be returned.”
This notification is made for an individual product taken back as a result of withdrawal from the contract or replacement. When the importer returns an imported product abroad, Article 24 of the guidance applies:
“Article 24- (1) When the importer returns an individual product it has imported, it makes a Return to Origin Notification.”
For all notification types, see our article on ÜTS individual movement notifications, and for carrying out these procedures, our page on the ÜTS individual notification procedures service.
10. Defect and Serious Adverse Event Reporting Are Separate Obligations
A defect is a breach of contract between the consumer and the seller. Reporting a serious adverse event is a manufacturer obligation under Article 85 of the Medical Device Regulation:
“Manufacturers of devices made available on the market, except investigational devices, report the following to the Agency and other relevant competent authorities in accordance with the fourth and sixth paragraphs of Article 89.”
For the reporting rules, see our article on vigilance and serious adverse event reporting.
11. Frequently Asked Questions
Which rights can a consumer exercise for a defective medical device?
Under Article 11 of Law No. 6502, the consumer chooses one of withdrawing from the contract, a price reduction, free repair or, if possible, replacement with a non-defective equivalent. The seller is obliged to fulfil this request.
We sold to a dealer; can the consumer apply to the importer?
Yes. The rights of free repair and replacement with a non-defective equivalent may also be exercised against the producer or importer. The importer is not held liable if it proves that the defect arose after the product was placed on the market.
Within how many days is a repair or replacement request fulfilled?
Within a maximum of thirty working days from the date the request is directed. For goods in the list annexed to the After-Sales Services Regulation, repair is subject to the maximum repair period in that regulation.
Is an error in the instructions for use considered a defect?
Article 8/2 of the Law considers goods that lack the characteristics stated in the introduction and instructions for use defective. Faulty installation due to an error in the installation instructions is also non-conforming performance.
What is done in ÜTS for a device taken back from a consumer?
When a device sold with a Notification of Delivery to Consumer is returned, a "Notification of Return Received from Consumer" is made for the number returned (Individual Movement Notifications Guidance, Art. 14/7).
For your ÜTS registration and individual notification procedures: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Sources



