Can a Physician Be the Responsible Manager? The Place of Physicians and Dentists in the Medical Device Sales Center: Article 10, Annex-4 and Related Prohibitions

SUMMARY
The answer to whether a physician can be a responsible manager is in Article 10 of the Tıbbi Cihaz Satış, Reklam ve Tanıtım Yönetmeliği (Medical Device Sales, Advertising and Promotion Regulation). The article sets a bachelor’s degree, the trainings in Article 35 and a single sales center as requirements; it does not list professions.
This article gives, as direct quotations, Article 10 and the regulatory provisions that directly concern physicians and dentists (definition of health professional, Annex-4, referral and incentive prohibitions, discipline, practice building), together with the work certificate process in the TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline.
For your ÜTS company and product registrations after the sales center authorization certificate: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Contents
1. Article 10: Requirements for the Responsible Manager
“(1) A responsible manager who meets the specified requirements is present at the sales center.”
“(2) The responsible manager must be a graduate of a higher education institution providing vocational education and training at least at the bachelor’s degree level, or a graduate of an education and training institution abroad in this field, with the equivalence of the diploma accepted by the competent authorities.”
“(3) The responsible manager documents that he or she has received the training required by Article 35.”
“(4) The responsible manager assumes responsibility for all activities of the sales center within the scope of this Regulation.”
“(5) The responsible manager cannot work at more than one sales center.”
Education: graduation at least at the bachelor’s level; equivalence for a foreign diploma.
Training: documentation of the training required by Article 35.
Responsibility: all activities of the sales center within the scope of this Regulation.
Limit: cannot work at more than one sales center.
There is no separate provision in the Regulation or the TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline on whether a physician or dentist can be a responsible manager. For details of the general requirements, see our article on sales center responsible manager requirements.
2. Physician and Dentist: Health Professional and Annex-4
The Regulation defines physicians and dentists as health professionals:
“l) Health professionals: Physicians, dentists, pharmacists, nurses, midwives and other professionals defined in additional Article 13 of Law No. 1219 of 11 April 1928 on the Manner of Practicing Medicine and Its Branches (Tababet ve Şuabatı San’atlarının Tarzı İcrasına Dair Kanun),”
Annex-4 lists the graduation fields for clinical support staff. Under the heading “Lisans” (Bachelor’s degree), the fields “Diş Hekimliği” (Dentistry) and “Tıp” (Medicine) appear. The education requirement for clinical support staff is in Article 12:
“(2) Clinical support staff must be a graduate of the fields specified in Annex-4 of a higher education institution providing vocational education and training at least at the associate degree level, or a graduate of an education and training institution abroad in this field, with the equivalence of the diploma accepted by the competent authorities.”
The TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline separately specifies the tasks clinical support staff cannot perform:
“(8) Clinical support staff may only give technical information to the user while the device is being used, provide technical training and, where necessary, inform about the usage features of the device through on-site application. However, clinical support staff cannot perform procedures that are regulated by the Regulation on Job and Task Definitions of Health Professionals and Other Professionals Working in Health Services (Sağlık Meslek Mensupları İle Sağlık Hizmetlerinde Çalışan Diğer Meslek Mensuplarının İş Ve Görev Tanımlarına Dair Yönetmelik), published in the Official Gazette dated 22 May 2014 and numbered 29007, and that fall within the job and task definitions of health professionals and other professionals working in health services.”
For the duties of clinical support staff, see our article on clinical support staff and other personnel.
3. Training and Qualification Certificate
“(1) Persons who will work as responsible manager, clinical support staff and sales and promotion staff at the sales center are required to attend the training program in Annex-1, to be organized by the Agency or by persons authorized by the Agency.”
In the Annex-1 training list, four titles are marked for the responsible manager (SM): legislation training, medical ethics training, training on working in sterile service areas and radiation safety training. According to Article 6 of the TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline, the work certificate is based on the qualification certificate:
“(1) The qualification certificates of the responsible manager, the sales and promotion staff and, where necessary, the clinical support staff who will work at the medical device sales center are submitted to the Directorate.”
“(2) For persons whose qualification certificates have been submitted, the Directorate issues the relevant one of the work certificates in Annex-3, Annex-4 and Annex-5.”
According to Article 9 of the Guideline, those who score seventy (70) or above in the exam are considered successful. For the training and exam process, see our article on TCESİS training and exam process.
4. Physician as Operator, Another Person as Responsible Manager
The sales center operator and the responsible manager can be different people. Article 5, paragraph 2, subparagraph (a) requires the following document in the application:
“a) Where the sales center operator is not the responsible manager, the written service contract concluded between the sales center operator and the responsible manager.”
The definition of the responsible manager states that responsibility is shared with the operator:
“o) Responsible manager: The person who is responsible, together with the operator, for the activities of sales centers within the scope of this Regulation and for whom a work certificate has been issued,”
5. Single Center, Absence and Notification of Change
Work certificates cannot be used for another sales center. Article 26, paragraph 3:
“(3) The work certificates of the responsible manager, the sales and promotion staff and the clinical support staff cannot be used for another sales center. However, where the device requires it, clinical support staff working within the manufacturer or importer may support another sales center.”
The responsible manager’s departure from the center is regulated in Article 10, paragraph 6:
“(6) If the responsible manager leaves the sales center for more than one week due to travel, illness or other force majeure, at least one of the sales and promotion staff or, if any, the clinical support staff for whom a work certificate has been issued under this Regulation is present at the sales center.”
If the responsible manager’s duty is terminated, he or she resigns or loses the requirements, under Article 10, paragraph 8 a notification is made to the Directorate within ten working days and a new responsible manager is assigned within thirty working days at the latest from the date of determination. If none is assigned, the center’s medical device sales activity is temporarily suspended.
6. Prohibitions and Discipline Concerning Physicians
The sales center’s prohibition on referral is in Article 8:
“(2) The sales center cannot refer users to any health institution, organization or physician.”
“(3) The sales center cannot refer users from any health service provider or physician to its own place of business, nor act as an intermediary for users.”
The prohibition on incentives is in Article 22:
“(1) In promotions, health professionals or technical staff working in the field of medical devices within health institutions and organizations cannot be encouraged to prescribe, use, purchase or recommend a device by giving money or gifts, providing any material gain, or promising a benefit or reward; and health professionals or technical staff working in the field of medical devices within health institutions and organizations cannot request or accept incentives.”
In case of violation, Article 28, paragraph 3 applies to health professionals:
“(3) (Amended: Official Gazette 26 May 2023-32202) Disciplinary proceedings are initiated at the institution or professional organization to which they are affiliated against health professionals or technical staff working in the field of medical devices within health institutions and organizations who act contrary to this Regulation.”
7. Sales Center in a Medical Practice Building
“(1) A sales center cannot be opened in a building that houses a health institution or organization, nor in its garden or annexes, except for buildings housing polyclinics and practices (muayenehane) opened by physicians and dentists, and laboratory diagnostic centers providing only analysis and imaging services, pharmacies, opticians, hearing aid centers, custom-made prosthesis and orthosis centers and dental prosthesis laboratories.”
Under Article 34, buildings housing polyclinics and practices opened by physicians and dentists are outside the places where a sales center cannot be opened. For physical requirements, see our article on sales center physical requirements.
8. Authorization Certificate and ÜTS Company Registration
The Annex-2 sample authorization certificate of the TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline contains the responsible manager’s name and surname and the number and date of the qualification certificate. Under Article 5 of the TCKKD-KLVZ-03 Guideline, a change of responsible manager is reflected in ÜTS through ÇKYS:
“(7) Where the responsible manager, title and address of the company change, if the relevant information is updated in ÇKYS, the changes are automatically updated in ÜTS.”
For the application, see our sales center authorization certificate application support page; for company registration, see our ÜTS company registration article.
9. Frequently Asked Questions
Can a physician or dentist be a responsible manager?
Article 10 of the Regulation does not name a profession; it sets the requirements of at least a bachelor’s degree, the trainings in Article 35 and a single sales center. There is no separate provision specific to physicians or dentists in the Regulation or the TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline.
Can a responsible manager work at more than one sales center?
No. Under Article 10, paragraph 5, the responsible manager cannot work at more than one sales center; under Article 26, the work certificate cannot be used for another sales center.
Can a physician own the company while someone else is the responsible manager?
Yes. Under Article 5, paragraph 2, subparagraph (a), where the operator is not the responsible manager, a written service contract between the operator and the responsible manager is submitted.
Can a physician be clinical support staff?
The Annex-4 bachelor’s fields include “Tıp” (Medicine) and “Diş Hekimliği” (Dentistry). According to the TCS-KLVZ-08 Guideline, procedures within the job and task definitions of health professionals cannot be performed by clinical support staff.
Can a sales center be opened in a building with a medical practice?
Article 34 excludes buildings housing polyclinics and practices opened by physicians and dentists from the places where a sales center cannot be opened.
For your ÜTS company and product registrations after the sales center authorization certificate: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Sources



