Medical Device Sales Center Inspection: Annex-2 Inspection Form, Administrative Sanctions, Suspension of Activity and Cancellation of the Authorization Certificate

SUMMARY
The inspection of sales centers is carried out, according to Article 27 of the Regulation on Medical Device Sales, Advertising and Promotion, by the provincial health directorate, mandatorily once every two years; where deemed necessary, the Agency also inspects. The periods in the Annex-2 inspection form are given for the deficiencies found.
In this article we give, through literal quotations (unofficial translations) from the regulation and the TİTCK guideline TCS-KLVZ-08, the scope of the inspection, the Annex-2 form, the administrative sanctions in Article 28, the registration system sanctions in Article 28/A, the temporary suspension of activity in Article 29, the cancellation of the authorization certificate in Article 30 and the effect on ÜTS.
For your sales center's ÜTS registrations and notifications: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Contents
1. Inspection: Who, How Often, What Is Inspected?2. Annex-2 Medical Device Sales Center Inspection Form3. Administrative Sanctions: Article 284. Sanctions Regarding the Registration and Information Management System: Article 28/A5. Temporary Suspension of Activity: Article 296. Permanent Closure: Cancellation of the Authorization Certificate (Article 30)7. Effect of Suspension and Cancellation on ÜTS8. Frequently Asked Questions
1. Inspection: Who, How Often, What Is Inspected?
Article 27 of the Regulation:
“(1) Sales centers are inspected by the directorate, mandatorily once every two years. They are also inspected by the Agency where deemed necessary.”
“(2) In sales centers, sales, promotion and advertising activities and all kinds of materials and methods used in these activities are inspected. The suspension, cancellation or correction of the information provided of sales, promotion and advertising activities that do not comply with the principles set out in this Regulation or that are found inappropriate in terms of public health is requested from the sales center. Requests in this direction are fulfilled without delay by the sales center.”
“(3) For the elimination of deficiencies or violations found in inspections, the sales center is given the periods determined in the inspection form in Annex-2, according to the nature of the deficiency or violation. At the end of this period, an on-site inspection is carried out again to determine whether the deficiencies have been eliminated. If the deficiencies or violations are not eliminated within this period, the activity of the sales center is suspended for the period specified in this form.”
“(4) The responsible manager of the sales center is obliged to show every facility during these inspections and to provide all kinds of information, documents and books requested.”
The directorate is, according to Article 4 of the Regulation, the provincial health directorate. Article 8, sixth paragraph, also regulates the retention of documents:
“(6) The sales center keeps the documents related to the activities it has carried out within the scope of this Regulation for five years and presents them upon the request of the Agency or the directorate.”
2. Annex-2 Medical Device Sales Center Inspection Form
The Annex-2 form contains six inspected matters, the sanction to be applied for each, and the sanction to be applied in case of repetition or continuation of the deficiency:
Is at least one staff member with a working certificate present at the center during working hours at a center that sells directly to individual users: a warning is given; if non-compliance is found in the second consecutive inspection, 15 days of temporary suspension of sales activity.
Are the devices stored under the conditions determined by the manufacturer and required by international standards: a warning is given, and if product safety is thought to be affected, the Agency is notified; if non-compliance is found in the second consecutive inspection, 15 days of temporary suspension of sales activity.
Are the devices sold registered in the Agency's registration and information management system: a warning is given and 15 days are allowed to eliminate the deficiency; if not eliminated, temporary suspension of activity until the deficiency is eliminated.
Have the individual notifications of the devices sold been made: a warning is given and 15 days are allowed; if not eliminated, 15 days of temporary suspension of activity.
Is there a refusal to provide the information and documents requested by the inspection team: a warning is given and 15 days are allowed; if not eliminated, 15 days of temporary suspension of activity.
Is there a situation not specified in the form but contrary to the provisions of the regulation: a warning is given and 15 days are allowed; if not eliminated, 15 days of temporary suspension of activity.
The 3rd and 4th rows of the form are directly related to ÜTS. The registration and notification obligation is in the fourth paragraph of Article 8:
“Sales centers are obliged to register the medical devices they place on the market or make available on the market in the registration and information management system created by the Agency, to keep the registered information up to date, and to carry out individual movement notification transactions in order to ensure the traceability of these devices.”
For the notifications, see our articles on ÜTS individual movement notifications; for storage and physical conditions, see our article on sales center physical conditions.
3. Administrative Sanctions: Article 28
“(1) As a result of the inspections, the sanctions specified in Articles 29 and 30 and in the inspection form in Annex-2 are applied to sales centers found to have acted contrary to this Regulation, according to the nature of their acts.”
The fourth paragraph, for staff:
“(4) In violations related to sales, promotion and clinical support carried out under this Regulation by the responsible manager, sales and promotion staff and clinical support staff within the validity period of the working certificate, these staff are first warned; in case of repetition, their working certificates are suspended for three months, and in case of continuation of the violation, for one year. The responsible manager, sales and promotion staff and clinical support staff whose working certificate is suspended cannot serve during this period.”
The other tiers in Article 28:
Violation of Article 21 (scientific and educational activities): the Agency warns; in case of violation within one year, a three-month ban from the promotion activities in Article 21; in case of repetition within one year after that, the person cannot participate in or contribute to scientific meetings and educational activities for one year (Art. 28/5).
Violation of the second, third or fourth paragraph of Article 25 (basic technical training and technical service training): first a warning, in case of repetition within one year, 15 days of suspension of sales activity (Art. 28/7).
Violation of 25/A, 25/B, 25/C or 25/Ç (warranty certificate): first a warning, a period of up to ninety days; if not eliminated, thirty days of suspension of sales activity (Art. 28/8).
Violation of the ninth paragraph of Article 26 (technical service obligations): first a warning; if not eliminated within thirty days after the warning or in case of repetition within one year, thirty days of suspension of sales activity (Art. 28/9).
The same sentence appears in the eighth and ninth paragraphs:
“The Agency may extend the period given for the elimination of the violation up to twice, if it decides that there is an exceptional situation not caused by the sales center.”
The second paragraph states that other laws will also be applied according to the nature of the act:
“(2) (Amended:OG-26/5/2023-32202) Those who act and operate contrary to the provisions specified in this Regulation are subject, according to the nature of their acts, to the provisions of Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 dated 26/9/2004, Law No. 6502 on Consumer Protection dated 7/11/2013, Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition dated 7/12/1994, Law No. 6112 on the Establishment and Broadcasting Services of Radio and Televisions dated 15/2/2011, Law No. 5651 on the Regulation of Publications on the Internet and Combating Crimes Committed Through Such Publications dated 4/5/2007, Misdemeanors Law No. 5326 dated 30/3/2005, Law No. 7223 and other relevant legislation.”
For warranty and technical service obligations, see our article on the medical device warranty certificate and technical service.
4. Sanctions Regarding the Registration and Information Management System: Article 28/A
“(1) If the Agency determines that applications have been made to the registration and information management systems with information and documents contrary to the truth, it may restrict the access of the persons or institutions carrying out these transactions to the relevant registration and information management systems.”
“(2) If it is determined that transactions have been repeatedly carried out in the Agency's registration and information management systems contrary to the procedures and principles determined by the Agency, the training received by the persons carrying out these transactions pursuant to the tenth paragraph of Article 26 of this Regulation is cancelled.”
The ninth paragraph of Article 11 of the TCS-KLVZ-08 guideline writes the consequence of the second paragraph in ÜTS:
“(9) Those determined to have carried out transactions within the scope of the second paragraph of Article 28/A of the Regulation are prevented from carrying out medical device registration transactions in ÜTS until they successfully complete the medical device registration clerk training and obtain a qualification certificate.”
For the registration clerk requirement, see our page on who the medical device registration clerk is.
5. Temporary Suspension of Activity: Article 29
“(1) In the following cases, the activity of the sales center is temporarily suspended for fifteen days:”
“a) Failure to send the information and documents requested by the directorate.”
“c) Failure to provide the information and documents requested by the inspection team during the inspection, or obstruction of the inspection.”
“ç) (Added:OG-26/5/2023-32202) Acting contrary to the seventh paragraph of Article 26.”
“d) (Added:OG-26/5/2023-32202) Engaging in activity contrary to the sanction applied within the scope of the fifth paragraph of Article 28.”
“e) (Added:OG-26/5/2023-32202) Acting contrary to the second paragraph of Article 31.”
Subparagraph (b) was repealed by the Official Gazette dated 2/9/2020 and numbered 31232. The two provisions referred to in the subparagraphs:
“(7) (Added:OG-26/5/2023-32202) It is prohibited for sales centers to sell devices to places not registered in the Agency's registration and information management system, except for the places specified in the guideline published by the Agency and except for the devices in Annex-3.”
“(2) Sales centers are obliged to immediately stop the sale of devices determined to be unsafe or contrary to technical regulations within the scope of market surveillance and inspection and the warning system and announced by the Agency, to return these devices to their manufacturer or importer; and, upon request, to share with the Agency all kinds of information and documents regarding the company, the user and the activities carried out on the subject related to the device sold.”
Procedure and repetition:
“(2) The temporary suspension of the activity of the sales center is carried out upon the proposal of the directorate and with the approval of the governorship. Sales centers whose activity is temporarily suspended are notified to the labor and employment agency provincial directorate and the provincial tax office.”
“(3) The authorization certificate, working certificates and identity cards issued under this Regulation for the sales center whose activity is temporarily suspended are kept by the directorate during the suspension period.”
“(5) In case of repetition within one year of the act requiring temporary suspension, the activity of the sales center is suspended for thirty days.”
There are also separate suspension provisions for the lack of a responsible manager or sales and promotion staff, for non-compliant advertising and non-compliant internet sales:
If the responsible manager leaves and a new one is not assigned within thirty working days at the latest, the medical device sales activity is temporarily suspended until a new one is assigned (Art. 10/8).
If the sales and promotion staff member leaves and a new one is not assigned within sixty working days at the latest, the sales activity is temporarily suspended until a new one is assigned (Art. 11/6).
For advertising contrary to the Regulation, a warning; if the nonconformity is not eliminated within three working days from the notification, the sales activity is suspended for 15 days (Art. 15/5).
For internet sales contrary to the Regulation, a warning; if the nonconformity is not eliminated within three working days from the notification, the sales activity is temporarily suspended for 15 days (Art. 26/6).
For advertising, see our article on medical device advertising and promotion rules; for internet sales, our articles on medical device internet sales.
6. Permanent Closure: Cancellation of the Authorization Certificate (Article 30)
“(1) (Amended:OG-2/9/2020-31232) The authorization certificate of the medical device sales center;”
“a) If it is determined that the deficiency found has not been eliminated at the end of the given period despite the application of temporary suspension of activity,”
“b) If it is determined that the medical device sales activity was continued during the period in which the temporary suspension penalty was applied,”
“c) An authorization certificate is not issued again within one year to natural and legal persons whose certificate has been cancelled a second time, and within two years to natural and legal persons whose certificate has been cancelled three times or more.”
Procedures to be carried out in case of cancellation:
“a) The permanent cancellation of the authorization certificate of the sales center is carried out upon the proposal of the directorate and with the approval of the governorship.”
“b) The sales center delivers the originals of the authorization certificate and working certificates issued under this Regulation, and the identity cards, to the directorate within fifteen days following the date of notification made to it.”
“c) The information that the sales center has been closed is notified to the labor and employment agency provincial directorate and the provincial tax office.”
Transfer and relocation without notification is also a ground for cancellation of the authorization certificate for the relevant address (Art. 32/3). For details, see our article on sales center relocation, transfer and closure.
7. Effect of Suspension and Cancellation on ÜTS
The fifth paragraph of Article 11 of the TCS-KLVZ-08 guideline:
“(5) The ÜTS registration and notification transactions of sales centers whose activity has been temporarily suspended in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation are blocked for the duration of the sanction. The ÜTS registration transactions of sales centers permanently closed in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation are stopped, thirty days are given for the notification transactions of their existing devices, and at the end of this period the notification transactions are also blocked.”
Temporary suspension: ÜTS registration and notification transactions are blocked for the duration of the suspension.
Permanent closure: ÜTS registration transactions are stopped; thirty days are given for the notifications of existing devices, then the notifications are also blocked.
For the responsibility of sales centers in the supply chain in the application of the sanction, the eighth paragraph of Article 26:
“(8) (Added:OG-26/5/2023-32202) All sales centers that place on the market and make available on the market the product subject to the sanction are jointly and severally liable in the application of administrative sanction decisions taken by the Agency within the scope of this Regulation or Law No. 7223.”
For the application, see our sales center authorization certificate application support page.
8. Frequently Asked Questions
How often is a sales center inspected?
According to the first paragraph of Article 27, it is inspected by the provincial health directorate, mandatorily once every two years. Where deemed necessary, it is also inspected by the Agency.
What happens if I do not provide the document requested during the inspection?
According to subparagraph (c) of the first paragraph of Article 29, if the information and documents requested by the inspection team are not provided or the inspection is obstructed, the activity is temporarily suspended for fifteen days. In case of repetition within one year, the period is thirty days.
Who decides on the suspension of activity?
According to the second paragraph of Article 29, the transaction is carried out upon the proposal of the directorate and with the approval of the governorship. During the suspension, the authorization certificate, working certificates and identity cards are kept by the directorate.
Can I carry out transactions in ÜTS if the activity is suspended?
According to Article 11/5 of TCS-KLVZ-08, ÜTS registration and notification transactions are blocked during the temporary suspension. In permanent closure, registration transactions are stopped and thirty days are given for notifications.
In which cases is the authorization certificate cancelled?
According to Article 30, it is cancelled if the deficiency is not eliminated at the end of the given period despite the suspension, or if sales continue during the suspension. No new authorization certificate is issued for one year after the second cancellation and for two years after three or more cancellations.
For your sales center's ÜTS registrations and notifications: Medical Device ÜTS Registration Consultancy
Sources
Mevzuat.gov.tr: Regulation on Medical Device Sales, Advertising and Promotion, Articles 4, 8, 10, 11, 15, 26, 27, 28, 28/A, 29, 30, 31 and 32, Annex-2
TİTCK: Guideline on the Implementation of the Regulation on Medical Device Sales, Advertising and Promotion (TCS-KLVZ-08, Rev. 04)



